top of page

Luigi's Mansion 3 and The Goob Syndrome

"The 'Goob' Enemies in Luigi's Mansion 3 are some of my favorite, yet least favorite ghosts in the franchise. But how come that I find these enemies great, yet awful?
To find out, I'm going to cover enemy behavior and its effect on the player!"

Summary

In this video essay, which was made before I started studying game design, I dive into the behavior states of the ghosts in Luigi's Mansion 3. I describe the AI patterns, the way the player reacts to it, and the context of the game world.

Using this analysis, I found an inconsistency in the 'Goob' ghosts, as their idle behavior didn't fit their role and aggressive behavior as enemies to the player.

However, this lead to me proposing an idea: player actions are also formed by the context and idle behavior of entities. Using this knowledge, unique player interactions can be created that focus on analyzing who it is that they are fighting, and creating your own strategy in reaction to that.

The Analysis

As preparation for the BUAS game design study, I decided to analyze Luigi’s Mansion 3, and specifically wanted to analyze one aspect: why did I really like AND dislike the standard enemies (the Goobs)?

goob introduction.jpg
The Goob enemies in Luigi's Mansion 3
Trying to lay out all enemy behavior and states in the game, and how it interacts with the player.
Picture1.png

So, I did research into enemy design: I looked up videos on the topic, played through the game and took my time to analyze how the enemies behaved in-game.

 

This way, I was able to categorize the enemy behavior, which gave me a clear overview of how the enemies interact with the player.

Now I noticed an inconsistency in the Goob's design. Their idle behavior made them seem very friendly and likeable, but they suddenly drop this behavior when they switch to their fighting behavior. The other ghosts didn’t have this inconsistency, they were clearly bad guys.

Picture2.png
Goobs, despite being enemies, perform everyday tasks
Picture3.png

But this conclusion also showed something interesting: the idle behavior of entities has enough effect on the player to influence their behavior. So even when entities aren’t changing the game’s world, a lot of information can still be conveyed.

Because the Goobs are so friendly and harmless when they aren't attacking the player...
...it almost seems illogical that you would need to fight them. The player's behavior is formed by what the enemy isn't doing.

And this is what I took out of this analysis: The interaction between players and the game world is not just formed by active changes in the world, but with idle information as well.

goob conclusion.jpg
bottom of page